Hah! I was right.
Wizard #176.
Are you happy with The Other?
Quesada: No, it didn't flow. Let's be honest. When you have that many creators in the room, things are gonna change.
Straczynski: Yeah, it was trial and error. Every so often, I would see huge divergences from what we had discussed. Had there been better communication during the writing process, I think it would have ebeen a much smoother experience.
Translated: It's crap.
Funny, DC don't have a problem with multiple creators on a series, but then again they don't use Reginald "Shit" Hudlin.
So The Other is a big piece of shit. But it might seem like heaven compared to whats to come, it looks like Marvel want to retcon Spider-man back to his roots. So end of marriage and back to working at the Bugle for the character then. 12 years of character growth down the toilet.
If you want to read "back-to-roots" Spider-man, that's what Ultimate Spider-man is for, or Spider-man Loves Mary-Jane, or Spider-man Adventures, or the plethora of graphic novels re-printing the classic stories, or the movies, or the cartoons. Its hardly like Classic Spider-man is an under-fed market.
I would rather take Spidey as he is now, the good and the bad, than have the character regress as if everything else didn't matter. Maybe they are right, maybe Spider-girl if the only pure Spider-man title left. Enjoy the last few issues while you can.
Saturday, April 29, 2006
Tuesday, April 25, 2006
Sunday, April 23, 2006
The Best He Is At What He Does?
Wolverines been a busy boy. Not only is he star of all the core X-books (last time I checked anyway, I havn't read X-Men and Uncanny for two/three years, but I do own them) and New Avengers, he now has two ongoing solo titles. The long running Wolverine and the newly released Wolverine: Origins.
It has been much lamented that the greatest thing about Marvel characters is that they are all flawed in some way, even the most altruistic of beings have a weakness or imperfection. Iron Man is a recovering alchoholic. The most powerful mutant in the world, Professor Xavier, is wheelchair-bound. Captian America is a man out of his time. Spider-man can never go back and erase the one mistake that cost him his Uncle.
This formula has proven most effective in the forty-five years Marvel since the dawn of the Silver Age of comics, out of the thousands of characters created since Stan Lee passed the torch to other creators, the only new creations who have really caught the publics attention have been flawed characters such as Gambit and Wolverine, Wolverine with his dark hidden past and berserker rage and Gambit with his, er, dark hidden past.
Its a formula that other creators have picked up on, such as Todd McFarlanes Spawn whose protagonist was so flawed he ended up in hell; where he sold his soul. Even iconic characters such as Supes and Batman have benefitted from this flawed formula, with Superman being ret-conned as a somewhat naive character at times and Batman being, well; a dick.
So it was with much trepidation that I awaited the first issue of Wolverine Origins (out now, with two covers, incuding one by Michael Turner - the most over-rated artist in comic). Daniel Way and Steve Dillon are a creative team that have really caught my eye lately, I have of course been a Steve Dillon fan dating back years to Hellblazer and the essential epic Preacher, liking his work so much that I have even bought two issues of WildCATs with his name on. Daniel Way I find to be somewhat hit and miss, but he knows how to write for his artists and as such, on all the collaborations with Dillon (Bullseye, Punisher Vs Bullseye) he has created brilliant moments for Steve Dillons art to shine. Catching the little minutae of details in facial expressions is Mr Dillons strong points, as he has one of the most versatile arrays of expressions of any artist I can think of (tied with Gary Frank).
So what could have put me off Wolverine Origins?
The thing that makes Wolverine work for me is that he has the dark past shrouded in mystery. Fuck the claws, ciagarettes and bad-boy attitude, it's dated and fucking stupid. Wolvie is a nomadic soul, wandering from place to place growing and evolving as he goes, making mistakes and learning from them - which has always been at odd's with the amount of team books he features in, but by giving him a family in the X-Men it has helped the character grow. Besides which - as the movie will attest to - Wolverine makes money.
So my thing is, if you erase the mystery surrounding his past, you'll lose a lot of his mistique (not the blue skinned shape-shifter). It would be like bringing Uncle Ben back, or Cap buying an I-pod or Superboy Prime punching on the walls of reality until Tony Stark's alchoholism was completely erased. The six issue Origin series was brilliantly crafted (by Paul Jenkins) as it added to the character, building another layer of intrigue to his past, but without the character having to confront his old demons. We know his origin, but he doesn't, so the character remains the same at the core, yet somehow more interesting.
However, with this new story-arc and the aftermath of "House of M", Wolverine knows everything. EVERYTHING. And we don't. But we can for £2.20 a month. This is the complete opposite of Origin and in my opinion is detrimental to Wolverine.
Wolverine Origins is a fairly fun book, like I said, it's got Dillon drawing it so I'm sold. However, I found his art lacking for the first time ever in this book, though the face detail and expressions on "Dum-Dum" Duggan and the SHIELD agents was brilliant, it could have been anyone in the Wolverine costume. He looked neither short, nor feral. After the good fun titles that Way and Dillon ahev put out before I was also expecting the book to be funnier, not slapstick and still serious, but with the occasional funny moment, but for the most part the book was flacid and insipid.
Wolverine is one of Marvels top-tier characters and a lot of eyes are going to be looking at the launch figures, as this is Marvels big book launch this month and so the pressure is really on for Way and Dillon, hopefully the title will pick up in a few months and find a stable selling ground which isn't inflated with variant cover gimmicks.
So what happens with the regular Wolverine title? Well, starting with Volume 2 #42 (#231 for numeric puritans like myself), the new creative team of Mark Guggenheim and Humberto Ramos debut.
I absolutely love Humberto Ramos, he is one of about only five artists that will actually inspire me to pick up a comic. Over the last few years his work has evolved more and more to the point where his work is more cartoony that main stream superhero art usually allows, but I love it to bits. From his early guest spot on Superboy, his run on Impulse, his self-published Cliffhanger title Crimson, through Spider-man and his more recent Revelations I have read it all and will quite happily follow him onto Wolverine.
Mark Guggenheim is a relative new-comer to comics, according to a quick google, he started out as an intern at Marvel before studying to be an attorney and writing for television, his first comics work was a fill-in stint on DC's Aquaman, he is a long-term comic fan contracted to stay with Wolverine for the 7 issue duration of Civil War, so it's quite a high profile first project gig.
But before we get to that, we have nexts weeks shipping Wolverine #41, a double sized fill-in issue which thankfully isn't double the price, a book which I just finished reading which prompted me to write this column.
Wow. Just wow.
This is what I want my Wolverine to be like. No Sabretooth this issue, no cigar's, no "Patch", no cussing, no whining about his lost past, no mention of dead ex-grilfriends (he is worse than Kyle Rayner on that front) and it doesn't matter what costume he is in. This is just Wolverine doing a job as a favour to a friend.
Now don't get me wrong, I like all the things I mentioned above, but the last few years they have overshadowed the rest of the character, the little bits of charecterisation that make Logan / James / Wolverine unique. His code of honour.
Most people forget how much time Wolverine spent travelling around the world, training as a Samurai. Logan is certainly not a man without morals, albeit a slightly twisted eye-for-an-eye sense of morals. This is the side of Wolverine that is seldom seen these days (if David Hayter and Bryan Singer don't show it, why should anyone else?) and made for a welcome change in this issue.
I feel like I should say what happens in this issue, but seeing the plot unfold is part of the joy of reading this issue by Stuart Morre and C P Smith, so I am going to resist the urge to gush and spill the beans. All I will say is, it was nice to see Wolverine fight down the berserker rage rather than welcoming it, and having an inner monlogue that wasn't just meaningless cliche.
This issue has reminded me why Wolverine is still a relevant character in modern fables despite all the shit surrounding his very convoluted origins. Wolverine is the best there is at what he does, and what he does isn't black and white.
It has been much lamented that the greatest thing about Marvel characters is that they are all flawed in some way, even the most altruistic of beings have a weakness or imperfection. Iron Man is a recovering alchoholic. The most powerful mutant in the world, Professor Xavier, is wheelchair-bound. Captian America is a man out of his time. Spider-man can never go back and erase the one mistake that cost him his Uncle.
This formula has proven most effective in the forty-five years Marvel since the dawn of the Silver Age of comics, out of the thousands of characters created since Stan Lee passed the torch to other creators, the only new creations who have really caught the publics attention have been flawed characters such as Gambit and Wolverine, Wolverine with his dark hidden past and berserker rage and Gambit with his, er, dark hidden past.
Its a formula that other creators have picked up on, such as Todd McFarlanes Spawn whose protagonist was so flawed he ended up in hell; where he sold his soul. Even iconic characters such as Supes and Batman have benefitted from this flawed formula, with Superman being ret-conned as a somewhat naive character at times and Batman being, well; a dick.
So it was with much trepidation that I awaited the first issue of Wolverine Origins (out now, with two covers, incuding one by Michael Turner - the most over-rated artist in comic). Daniel Way and Steve Dillon are a creative team that have really caught my eye lately, I have of course been a Steve Dillon fan dating back years to Hellblazer and the essential epic Preacher, liking his work so much that I have even bought two issues of WildCATs with his name on. Daniel Way I find to be somewhat hit and miss, but he knows how to write for his artists and as such, on all the collaborations with Dillon (Bullseye, Punisher Vs Bullseye) he has created brilliant moments for Steve Dillons art to shine. Catching the little minutae of details in facial expressions is Mr Dillons strong points, as he has one of the most versatile arrays of expressions of any artist I can think of (tied with Gary Frank).
So what could have put me off Wolverine Origins?
The thing that makes Wolverine work for me is that he has the dark past shrouded in mystery. Fuck the claws, ciagarettes and bad-boy attitude, it's dated and fucking stupid. Wolvie is a nomadic soul, wandering from place to place growing and evolving as he goes, making mistakes and learning from them - which has always been at odd's with the amount of team books he features in, but by giving him a family in the X-Men it has helped the character grow. Besides which - as the movie will attest to - Wolverine makes money.
So my thing is, if you erase the mystery surrounding his past, you'll lose a lot of his mistique (not the blue skinned shape-shifter). It would be like bringing Uncle Ben back, or Cap buying an I-pod or Superboy Prime punching on the walls of reality until Tony Stark's alchoholism was completely erased. The six issue Origin series was brilliantly crafted (by Paul Jenkins) as it added to the character, building another layer of intrigue to his past, but without the character having to confront his old demons. We know his origin, but he doesn't, so the character remains the same at the core, yet somehow more interesting.
However, with this new story-arc and the aftermath of "House of M", Wolverine knows everything. EVERYTHING. And we don't. But we can for £2.20 a month. This is the complete opposite of Origin and in my opinion is detrimental to Wolverine.
Wolverine Origins is a fairly fun book, like I said, it's got Dillon drawing it so I'm sold. However, I found his art lacking for the first time ever in this book, though the face detail and expressions on "Dum-Dum" Duggan and the SHIELD agents was brilliant, it could have been anyone in the Wolverine costume. He looked neither short, nor feral. After the good fun titles that Way and Dillon ahev put out before I was also expecting the book to be funnier, not slapstick and still serious, but with the occasional funny moment, but for the most part the book was flacid and insipid.
Wolverine is one of Marvels top-tier characters and a lot of eyes are going to be looking at the launch figures, as this is Marvels big book launch this month and so the pressure is really on for Way and Dillon, hopefully the title will pick up in a few months and find a stable selling ground which isn't inflated with variant cover gimmicks.
So what happens with the regular Wolverine title? Well, starting with Volume 2 #42 (#231 for numeric puritans like myself), the new creative team of Mark Guggenheim and Humberto Ramos debut.
I absolutely love Humberto Ramos, he is one of about only five artists that will actually inspire me to pick up a comic. Over the last few years his work has evolved more and more to the point where his work is more cartoony that main stream superhero art usually allows, but I love it to bits. From his early guest spot on Superboy, his run on Impulse, his self-published Cliffhanger title Crimson, through Spider-man and his more recent Revelations I have read it all and will quite happily follow him onto Wolverine.
Mark Guggenheim is a relative new-comer to comics, according to a quick google, he started out as an intern at Marvel before studying to be an attorney and writing for television, his first comics work was a fill-in stint on DC's Aquaman, he is a long-term comic fan contracted to stay with Wolverine for the 7 issue duration of Civil War, so it's quite a high profile first project gig.
But before we get to that, we have nexts weeks shipping Wolverine #41, a double sized fill-in issue which thankfully isn't double the price, a book which I just finished reading which prompted me to write this column.
Wow. Just wow.
This is what I want my Wolverine to be like. No Sabretooth this issue, no cigar's, no "Patch", no cussing, no whining about his lost past, no mention of dead ex-grilfriends (he is worse than Kyle Rayner on that front) and it doesn't matter what costume he is in. This is just Wolverine doing a job as a favour to a friend.
Now don't get me wrong, I like all the things I mentioned above, but the last few years they have overshadowed the rest of the character, the little bits of charecterisation that make Logan / James / Wolverine unique. His code of honour.
Most people forget how much time Wolverine spent travelling around the world, training as a Samurai. Logan is certainly not a man without morals, albeit a slightly twisted eye-for-an-eye sense of morals. This is the side of Wolverine that is seldom seen these days (if David Hayter and Bryan Singer don't show it, why should anyone else?) and made for a welcome change in this issue.
I feel like I should say what happens in this issue, but seeing the plot unfold is part of the joy of reading this issue by Stuart Morre and C P Smith, so I am going to resist the urge to gush and spill the beans. All I will say is, it was nice to see Wolverine fight down the berserker rage rather than welcoming it, and having an inner monlogue that wasn't just meaningless cliche.
This issue has reminded me why Wolverine is still a relevant character in modern fables despite all the shit surrounding his very convoluted origins. Wolverine is the best there is at what he does, and what he does isn't black and white.
Wednesday, April 19, 2006
Civil War Checklist
Okay, y'know how Civil War didn't look too bad as a crossover, just a few tie-ins here and there? Its grown. A lot. The following is a complete checklist for Civil War including known variants. If you buy every single issue from my store I will buy you a mint Cornetto.
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #529
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN 2ND PTG #529
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN 3RD PTG #529
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #530
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #531
CIVIL WAR OPENING SHOT SPECIAL PROMO SKETCHBOOK
FANTASTIC FOUR #536
FANTASTIC FOUR 2ND PTG HITCH VAR #536
FANTASTIC FOUR #537
NEW AVENGERS ILLUMINATI SPECIAL
CIVIL WAR #1 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #1 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER SKETCH VARIANT #1 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #2 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #2 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #3 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #3 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #4 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #4 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #5 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #5 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #6 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #6 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #7 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #7 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR FRONT LINE #1 (OF 10)
CIVIL WAR FRONT LINE #2
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #532
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #533
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #534
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #535
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #536
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #537
BLACK PANTHER #18
CABLE DEADPOOL #30
CABLE DEADPOOL #31
CABLE DEADPOOL #32
CAPTAIN AMERICA #22
CAPTAIN AMERICA #23
CAPTAIN AMERICA #24
CIVIL WAR YOUNG AVENGERS & RUNAWAYS #1
CIVIL WAR YOUNG AVENGERS & RUNAWAYS #2
CIVIL WAR YOUNG AVENGERS & RUNAWAYS #3
CIVIL WAR YOUNG AVENGERS & RUNAWAYS #4
CIVIL WAR X-MEN #1
CIVIL WAR X-MEN #2
CIVIL WAR X-MEN #3
CIVIL WAR X-MEN #4
DAILY BUGLE CIVIL WAR EDITION
FANTASTIC FOUR #538
FANTASTIC FOUR #539
FANTASTIC FOUR #540
FANTASTIC FOUR #541
FANTASTIC FOUR #542
FANTASTIC FOUR #543
HEROES FOR HIRE #1
HEROES FOR HIRE #2
HEROES FOR HIRE #3
IRON MAN #13
IRON MAN #14
MARVEL SPOTLIGHT MARK MILLAR STEVE MCNIVEN
MS MARVEL #6
MS MARVEL #7
MS MARVEL #8
NEW AVENGERS #21
NEW AVENGERS #22
NEW AVENGERS #23
NEW AVENGERS #24
NEW AVENGERS #25
PUNISHER WAR JOURNAL #1
PUNISHER WAR JOURNAL #2
PUNISHER WAR JOURNAL #3
SHE-HULK 2 #8
THUNDERBOLTS #103
THUNDERBOLTS #104
THUNDERBOLTS #105
WOLVERINE #42
WOLVERINE #43
WOLVERINE #44
WOLVERINE #45
WOLVERINE #46
WOLVERINE #47
X-FACTOR #8
X-FACTOR #9
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #529
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN 2ND PTG #529
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN 3RD PTG #529
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #530
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #531
CIVIL WAR OPENING SHOT SPECIAL PROMO SKETCHBOOK
FANTASTIC FOUR #536
FANTASTIC FOUR 2ND PTG HITCH VAR #536
FANTASTIC FOUR #537
NEW AVENGERS ILLUMINATI SPECIAL
CIVIL WAR #1 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #1 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER SKETCH VARIANT #1 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #2 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #2 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #3 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #3 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #4 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #4 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #5 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #5 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #6 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #6 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR #7 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR TURNER VARIANT #7 (OF 7)
CIVIL WAR FRONT LINE #1 (OF 10)
CIVIL WAR FRONT LINE #2
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #532
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #533
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #534
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #535
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #536
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #537
BLACK PANTHER #18
CABLE DEADPOOL #30
CABLE DEADPOOL #31
CABLE DEADPOOL #32
CAPTAIN AMERICA #22
CAPTAIN AMERICA #23
CAPTAIN AMERICA #24
CIVIL WAR YOUNG AVENGERS & RUNAWAYS #1
CIVIL WAR YOUNG AVENGERS & RUNAWAYS #2
CIVIL WAR YOUNG AVENGERS & RUNAWAYS #3
CIVIL WAR YOUNG AVENGERS & RUNAWAYS #4
CIVIL WAR X-MEN #1
CIVIL WAR X-MEN #2
CIVIL WAR X-MEN #3
CIVIL WAR X-MEN #4
DAILY BUGLE CIVIL WAR EDITION
FANTASTIC FOUR #538
FANTASTIC FOUR #539
FANTASTIC FOUR #540
FANTASTIC FOUR #541
FANTASTIC FOUR #542
FANTASTIC FOUR #543
HEROES FOR HIRE #1
HEROES FOR HIRE #2
HEROES FOR HIRE #3
IRON MAN #13
IRON MAN #14
MARVEL SPOTLIGHT MARK MILLAR STEVE MCNIVEN
MS MARVEL #6
MS MARVEL #7
MS MARVEL #8
NEW AVENGERS #21
NEW AVENGERS #22
NEW AVENGERS #23
NEW AVENGERS #24
NEW AVENGERS #25
PUNISHER WAR JOURNAL #1
PUNISHER WAR JOURNAL #2
PUNISHER WAR JOURNAL #3
SHE-HULK 2 #8
THUNDERBOLTS #103
THUNDERBOLTS #104
THUNDERBOLTS #105
WOLVERINE #42
WOLVERINE #43
WOLVERINE #44
WOLVERINE #45
WOLVERINE #46
WOLVERINE #47
X-FACTOR #8
X-FACTOR #9
DAREDEVIL
Going onto Daredevil as the new ongoing writer after Kevin Smiths run must have been very hard on the then rising star Brian Michael Bendis, but he really got his hooks into the character, came up with an new-direction for the title and replaced the formulaic superhero artwork for the grim "used" artwork of Alex Maleev. Throughout his near 50 issue run, Bendis exposed Matt Murdock as Daredevil, married the characeter off, gave Bullseye the shitty movie target engraved on his head but in a way that really worked, arranged a massive internal coup that nearly killed Kingpin, had DD fight an entire ninja clan on the streets of Hells Kitchen, killed off Kingpins wife (his only stabalising influence and weakness), declared Matt the new Kingpin of NY and eventually imprisoned him. My only fear throughout the entire run was what would the replacement writer do once Bendis left?
Going onto Daredevil as the new ongoing writer after Brian Michael Bendis must have been almost impossible for Ed Brubaker.
A lesser writer would have found a loophole to pull DD out of prison, or written off the last 5 years as a dream, hoax or imaginary tale (even better, he could have shed his skin, gone into a cocoon and developed stabby wrist things). In the Marvel Universe it wouldn't be impossible for the Avengers to act as character witnesses to free DD, but then that would have rendered the entire Bendis run obsolete. Instead, Ed Brubaker has picked up the ball exactly where BMB left it and is running with it.
Only a few issues in, and we have already seen all the movers and shakers in Rikers prison attempt to kill Matt (lets face it, a good chunk of them are in there because of DD or people like him) and the death of long-term Matt confidant Foggy Nelson. An excellent supporting cast keep the story moving outside of prison with Ben Urich attempting to clear Matt's name, and the apperance of a new DD on the streets of Hells Kitchen means we also get superhero bang for our buck in this prison drama. And wait 'till you see Frank Castles reaction to the violent outbursts in Rikers Prison.
After the last few years of DD's life, he has lost everything, the inmates of Rikers are about to find out that a man with nothing to lose is truly a Man Without Fear.
Going onto Daredevil as the new ongoing writer after Brian Michael Bendis must have been almost impossible for Ed Brubaker.
A lesser writer would have found a loophole to pull DD out of prison, or written off the last 5 years as a dream, hoax or imaginary tale (even better, he could have shed his skin, gone into a cocoon and developed stabby wrist things). In the Marvel Universe it wouldn't be impossible for the Avengers to act as character witnesses to free DD, but then that would have rendered the entire Bendis run obsolete. Instead, Ed Brubaker has picked up the ball exactly where BMB left it and is running with it.
Only a few issues in, and we have already seen all the movers and shakers in Rikers prison attempt to kill Matt (lets face it, a good chunk of them are in there because of DD or people like him) and the death of long-term Matt confidant Foggy Nelson. An excellent supporting cast keep the story moving outside of prison with Ben Urich attempting to clear Matt's name, and the apperance of a new DD on the streets of Hells Kitchen means we also get superhero bang for our buck in this prison drama. And wait 'till you see Frank Castles reaction to the violent outbursts in Rikers Prison.
After the last few years of DD's life, he has lost everything, the inmates of Rikers are about to find out that a man with nothing to lose is truly a Man Without Fear.
A Tale of One Good Comic
I'll never know why Beatrix Potter, Roger Hargreaves and Raymond Briggs are considered to be excellent childrens story-tellers whilst the rest of the comic book medium gets written off as a low-brow form of illiterate story-telling by the mass media.
Indeed, the parables and cautionary tales of titles such as "When the Wind Blows" are just as relevant to adults as they are to children, yet by being listed as childrens books in librarys they are often shunned by the elder reader.
When Will Eisner coined the phrase "Graphic Novel", few realised what an important name it was, as it describes itself to a wide audience, free of ageist stigma or even class snobbism of "comic-books" being for the uneducated.
There is some argument as to what defines the term "graphic novel", too many; it is any comic with a spine, to most; it is any comic presented for the first time in its original format as a complete collection (such as the ground-breaking "A Contract With God"). To me, a graphic novel can be anything that feels like it is a complete story, novel or novella presented as one volume. Maus is a graphic novel. The Dark Knight Returns is a graphic novel. Watchmen is a graphic novel. Ultimate Spider-man volume 7 is a Trade Paperback.
Then there are phonebooks like Cerebus, buts that's a different column altogether.
This column is about the amazing graphic novel: Tale of One Bad Rat by Brian Talbot.
Despite being printed originally as a mini-series, it is undoubtably a comic meant for GN. I would like to guess that every School and Library would have a copy of this book in stock, but alas, I doubt that to be true.
Although this book came out around the same time I was getting into comics, I only recently got around to reading it after Glyn put me onto it (see, he has some good points) - although I have no idea if he has read it or just read about it in the pages of Comics International.
This book deals with the subject of child abuse, and the effects it has on the victims. Incredibly heavily researched, Brian Talbot read as many books as he could find on the subject matter and talked to many victims, and the one thing that was parralelled in all accounts was that the victim feels like they are the ones in the wrong.
Coupled together with the protagonists journey retracing the steps of Beatrix Potter throughout the Lake District, it makes for a compelling read, with many clever touches and symbolism spread throughout this beautifully crafted graphic novel.
Indeed, the parables and cautionary tales of titles such as "When the Wind Blows" are just as relevant to adults as they are to children, yet by being listed as childrens books in librarys they are often shunned by the elder reader.
When Will Eisner coined the phrase "Graphic Novel", few realised what an important name it was, as it describes itself to a wide audience, free of ageist stigma or even class snobbism of "comic-books" being for the uneducated.
There is some argument as to what defines the term "graphic novel", too many; it is any comic with a spine, to most; it is any comic presented for the first time in its original format as a complete collection (such as the ground-breaking "A Contract With God"). To me, a graphic novel can be anything that feels like it is a complete story, novel or novella presented as one volume. Maus is a graphic novel. The Dark Knight Returns is a graphic novel. Watchmen is a graphic novel. Ultimate Spider-man volume 7 is a Trade Paperback.
Then there are phonebooks like Cerebus, buts that's a different column altogether.
This column is about the amazing graphic novel: Tale of One Bad Rat by Brian Talbot.
Despite being printed originally as a mini-series, it is undoubtably a comic meant for GN. I would like to guess that every School and Library would have a copy of this book in stock, but alas, I doubt that to be true.
Although this book came out around the same time I was getting into comics, I only recently got around to reading it after Glyn put me onto it (see, he has some good points) - although I have no idea if he has read it or just read about it in the pages of Comics International.
This book deals with the subject of child abuse, and the effects it has on the victims. Incredibly heavily researched, Brian Talbot read as many books as he could find on the subject matter and talked to many victims, and the one thing that was parralelled in all accounts was that the victim feels like they are the ones in the wrong.
Coupled together with the protagonists journey retracing the steps of Beatrix Potter throughout the Lake District, it makes for a compelling read, with many clever touches and symbolism spread throughout this beautifully crafted graphic novel.
Saturday, April 15, 2006
Fables Vol. 1 - The Greatest Smelling Read in Comics
Why do Comics smell so good?
Possibly my geekiest column entry ever.
Long term comic fans will know what I mean, there is a certain smell about comics, especially '70's / '80's comics with there newspaper quality stock. Comics these days don't smell as good as they used to.
In fact, Top Cow comics smell downright awful, which is another reason not to read them.
This column was sparked after I was flicking through the Fables vol. 1 tpb, which as well as being a great read smells awesome.
Or maybe only sleeping 4 hours a night for the last few nights is starting to get to me.
Thursday, April 13, 2006
Those who do, do. Those who don't, talk about it.
So, I'm not saying a thing, other than for the first time in a little while my writing is going really well, and despite all my other commitments I am going to try my damn hardest to get things moving along.
Even if I don't get anything published, I want a nice collection of rejection letters, because at the end of the day, that's further than most people will get.
"I tried didn't I? At least I did that."
In other news, Marvel are publishing a new Heroes for Hire series, because they figured they didn't have enough books selling below 20k.
Awesome.
Even if I don't get anything published, I want a nice collection of rejection letters, because at the end of the day, that's further than most people will get.
"I tried didn't I? At least I did that."
In other news, Marvel are publishing a new Heroes for Hire series, because they figured they didn't have enough books selling below 20k.
Awesome.
Sunday, April 09, 2006
SUPERBOY
Superboy means different things to different people. If you are the Seigal heirs, it means a pay check. If you are a teen girl, it probably means Smallville. If you a long term Superman fan, it means the adventures of Superman as a child. But to me, it means Conner Kent, the Clone of Superman.
On a recent column, Erik Larsen discussed why the character Nova was so important to him: it was the one character that felt like his. Superman, Batman, Spider-man and the Fantastic Four had all been established super heroes by the time a young Erik larsen found his way into comic stores, but Nova was new to his generation and he was in at entry level for better of for worse. This is how I feel about Superboy and the Teen Titans.
I started reading comics more recent than most people think: 1996.
Don't get me wrong, growing up I had always read the UK Transformers comic, and being British, every now and then I recieved a Superman or Fantastic Four annual for Christmas. I had borrowed from my brothers friend "Batman: A Death in the Family" and sat and read the entire "Death of Superman" Tpb in WH Smiths, and even though I didn't keep up with DC or fully understand the "shared universe" concept, I knew these two books were important.
But it was only when a small comic shop opened in my home town and I went in looking for Star Wars figures and I reached disposable income age that I really found out what comics really were.
At the time I found the comic store, my parents had just gone through a massive, incredibly nasty and not at all amicable divorce which left my Mother, Brother and I penniless and I had to start working on top of GCSE's just to help my mother pay the mortgage, which then after reposesion became rent money. So the spare bit of money I had was very important to me.
In fact, friends dating back to that time can still recollect my enviable wish of: "If I won the lottery, I'd put Spider-man on standing order", a wish which bought a wry smile to my face this week when a fairly new comic customer said the same thing about buying graphic novels.
Through that comic shop I found a lot of friends, many of whom I still know now and indeed, it is the very shop that I work now and can call, at least in part, mine.
One of the first comics I was put onto was Superboy, my friend Pete loved the character and indeed all things Superman related, but we both got caught up in the hype of things like Age of Apocalypse, Maximum Clonage and Gen 13 (which I still love, so shut up) and Superboy initally had to wait in the wake of massive crossovers and variant covers (the past is the present is the past).
Still, eventually I got into the adventures of Superboy, Impulse and Robin. Superman, Batman, Flash, Wonder Woman and all the big DC players held little interest to me as I was after all a Marvellite through and through, but the three minor players with their recent launches and issue #1's seemed a whole lot more accessable.
Unfortunately, I had got into comics in one of the bleakest periods of comic history. Marvel had filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy and comic shops and companys were closing down left right and center; a few times it seemed like the comic shop I frequented would follow the fate of so many others, and many new Marvel characters never got of the ground, facing poor sales and cancellation . But DC, subsidised by their parent company Warner Bros. kept newer titles like Superboy afloat.
Superboy was ace in the early days, a clone of Superman with substituted powers to emulate the Man of Steels ability, such as tactile telekenesis. Karl Kesel and Tom Grummett handled the character, with a couple of fill-in issues by Humberto Ramos which led to me buying the Impulse title. The entire storyline with Superboy and Knockouts relationship was brilliantly handled, and was a portent of things to come for the choices Superboy would later have to make in Teen Titans.
For a time, Superboy even had a spin-off title, the ill-fated "Superboy and the Ravers", things seemed bright for the kid of Steel, and I still remember the wave of excitement I felt when DC announced "Young Justice", an ongoing team-up book starring S'Boy, Robin and Impulse.
As I grew up, comics grew up with me. My comic hobby became my job and I started reading more and more comics, for a comic sales clerk is only as good as his recomendations, and eventually Superboy fell to the wayside. Robin had started to grow up, taking responsibility and becoming a natural leader. Impulse had a few times hinted to greater things and maturity. But Superboy just seemed to limp from one set of creators to another never growing or evolving. True, he always had to battle with the fact he was living in the greatest shadow ever cast in the DCU, which anyone with an older sibling can tell you is not an easy thing to have to do, and it seemed obvious to anyone that Superboy would never go anywhere as long as Superman was around, and let's face it DC are never going to rid themselves of such an icon.
The character had lost all direction, the fun-loving-sun-drenched-Calafornia-mallrat-generation x- surfer-image had reached its limits, dying a death along with Pauly Shore and Superboy was "re-invented" many times, as a modern day Kamandi, then he lost his powers, eventually becoming a tenement building super-intendant and - unless you are Will Eisner - it's not easy to tell tenement building stories.
Superboy was cancelled unsurprisingly at issue 100, and faded into brief obscurity after the cancellation of Young Justice.
Gone, but not forgotten.
Marvels market dominance, after their financial and creative post-bankruptcy reshuffle, had established them as major players and each and every month, DC watched as Marvels unit and dollar ahare increased. Out there in comicbook fandom world we had no idea, but the wheels at DC started to turn again.
With the combined forces of Judd Winnick and Geoff Johns, the DCU had a massive shake up, re-creating Young Justice as The (new-new-new) Teen Titans.
Superboy was back, and this time, he had a purpose. He struggled with his heritage after finding out his DNA was part Superman and Luthor, and he started to ignore his friends and deny his heroism.
I have always said that the greatest comic characters are those who are flawed, as any story in about conflict, resolution and the choices the characters make along the way. If any character is too pure or altruistic, the suspense and choice is diminished, that's why Batman and Spider-man are the two greatest known heroes in the world, they both are inherantly flawed (Bat's is an oedopeidic nut-ball whose childhood was ripped from him, and Spider-man can never atone for that one mistake).
The perfect clone that was Superboy, was now flawed. And thus, became a character, not just a characterisation.
Now if you have not read the Geoff Johns Teen Titans run, you really have no excuse, they are all available in Tpb (dirt cheap too). EVERYONE who reads Infinite Crisis should read these titles, and after the events of Infinite Crisis #6, we all know what choices Superboy made.
Superboy is dead, and has done more in his death than most comic characters have in their entire 40-60 year heritage. Be thankful for characters that are more than just profit making icons.
On a recent column, Erik Larsen discussed why the character Nova was so important to him: it was the one character that felt like his. Superman, Batman, Spider-man and the Fantastic Four had all been established super heroes by the time a young Erik larsen found his way into comic stores, but Nova was new to his generation and he was in at entry level for better of for worse. This is how I feel about Superboy and the Teen Titans.
I started reading comics more recent than most people think: 1996.
Don't get me wrong, growing up I had always read the UK Transformers comic, and being British, every now and then I recieved a Superman or Fantastic Four annual for Christmas. I had borrowed from my brothers friend "Batman: A Death in the Family" and sat and read the entire "Death of Superman" Tpb in WH Smiths, and even though I didn't keep up with DC or fully understand the "shared universe" concept, I knew these two books were important.
But it was only when a small comic shop opened in my home town and I went in looking for Star Wars figures and I reached disposable income age that I really found out what comics really were.
At the time I found the comic store, my parents had just gone through a massive, incredibly nasty and not at all amicable divorce which left my Mother, Brother and I penniless and I had to start working on top of GCSE's just to help my mother pay the mortgage, which then after reposesion became rent money. So the spare bit of money I had was very important to me.
In fact, friends dating back to that time can still recollect my enviable wish of: "If I won the lottery, I'd put Spider-man on standing order", a wish which bought a wry smile to my face this week when a fairly new comic customer said the same thing about buying graphic novels.
Through that comic shop I found a lot of friends, many of whom I still know now and indeed, it is the very shop that I work now and can call, at least in part, mine.
One of the first comics I was put onto was Superboy, my friend Pete loved the character and indeed all things Superman related, but we both got caught up in the hype of things like Age of Apocalypse, Maximum Clonage and Gen 13 (which I still love, so shut up) and Superboy initally had to wait in the wake of massive crossovers and variant covers (the past is the present is the past).
Still, eventually I got into the adventures of Superboy, Impulse and Robin. Superman, Batman, Flash, Wonder Woman and all the big DC players held little interest to me as I was after all a Marvellite through and through, but the three minor players with their recent launches and issue #1's seemed a whole lot more accessable.
Unfortunately, I had got into comics in one of the bleakest periods of comic history. Marvel had filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy and comic shops and companys were closing down left right and center; a few times it seemed like the comic shop I frequented would follow the fate of so many others, and many new Marvel characters never got of the ground, facing poor sales and cancellation . But DC, subsidised by their parent company Warner Bros. kept newer titles like Superboy afloat.
Superboy was ace in the early days, a clone of Superman with substituted powers to emulate the Man of Steels ability, such as tactile telekenesis. Karl Kesel and Tom Grummett handled the character, with a couple of fill-in issues by Humberto Ramos which led to me buying the Impulse title. The entire storyline with Superboy and Knockouts relationship was brilliantly handled, and was a portent of things to come for the choices Superboy would later have to make in Teen Titans.
For a time, Superboy even had a spin-off title, the ill-fated "Superboy and the Ravers", things seemed bright for the kid of Steel, and I still remember the wave of excitement I felt when DC announced "Young Justice", an ongoing team-up book starring S'Boy, Robin and Impulse.
As I grew up, comics grew up with me. My comic hobby became my job and I started reading more and more comics, for a comic sales clerk is only as good as his recomendations, and eventually Superboy fell to the wayside. Robin had started to grow up, taking responsibility and becoming a natural leader. Impulse had a few times hinted to greater things and maturity. But Superboy just seemed to limp from one set of creators to another never growing or evolving. True, he always had to battle with the fact he was living in the greatest shadow ever cast in the DCU, which anyone with an older sibling can tell you is not an easy thing to have to do, and it seemed obvious to anyone that Superboy would never go anywhere as long as Superman was around, and let's face it DC are never going to rid themselves of such an icon.
The character had lost all direction, the fun-loving-sun-drenched-Calafornia-mallrat-generation x- surfer-image had reached its limits, dying a death along with Pauly Shore and Superboy was "re-invented" many times, as a modern day Kamandi, then he lost his powers, eventually becoming a tenement building super-intendant and - unless you are Will Eisner - it's not easy to tell tenement building stories.
Superboy was cancelled unsurprisingly at issue 100, and faded into brief obscurity after the cancellation of Young Justice.
Gone, but not forgotten.
Marvels market dominance, after their financial and creative post-bankruptcy reshuffle, had established them as major players and each and every month, DC watched as Marvels unit and dollar ahare increased. Out there in comicbook fandom world we had no idea, but the wheels at DC started to turn again.
With the combined forces of Judd Winnick and Geoff Johns, the DCU had a massive shake up, re-creating Young Justice as The (new-new-new) Teen Titans.
Superboy was back, and this time, he had a purpose. He struggled with his heritage after finding out his DNA was part Superman and Luthor, and he started to ignore his friends and deny his heroism.
I have always said that the greatest comic characters are those who are flawed, as any story in about conflict, resolution and the choices the characters make along the way. If any character is too pure or altruistic, the suspense and choice is diminished, that's why Batman and Spider-man are the two greatest known heroes in the world, they both are inherantly flawed (Bat's is an oedopeidic nut-ball whose childhood was ripped from him, and Spider-man can never atone for that one mistake).
The perfect clone that was Superboy, was now flawed. And thus, became a character, not just a characterisation.
Now if you have not read the Geoff Johns Teen Titans run, you really have no excuse, they are all available in Tpb (dirt cheap too). EVERYONE who reads Infinite Crisis should read these titles, and after the events of Infinite Crisis #6, we all know what choices Superboy made.
Superboy is dead, and has done more in his death than most comic characters have in their entire 40-60 year heritage. Be thankful for characters that are more than just profit making icons.
Saturday, April 01, 2006
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)